- We track 12 implant planning tools; only 11 have enough public data to compare, and just 2 have any public review at all (coDiagnostiX, 1 review; Simplant, 3 reviews) — both too thin to cite as a rating. Pick by library, fees and ecosystem below, not by stars.
- Open implant library: 6 of 11 (3Shape Implant Studio, coDiagnostiX, exoplan, RealGUIDE, SICAT Implant, and Simplant) document an open library you can add any manufacturer's implant to. Size varies hugely where it's published: coDiagnostiX claims 8,000 implants, Simplant 10,000, exoplan 250 — if you place implants from a brand outside a closed or small library, you may not be able to plan the case at all.
- Guide export fee — the real recurring cost — is published by only 3 of 11: exoplan is free (bundled with its exocad ecosystem), Blue Sky Plan charges $6/case, Implant Concierge $50/case. Everyone else is silent on this, and it matters more than the software's sticker price if you're printing a guide per case.
- Only coDiagnostiX publishes real self-serve monthly pricing ($0 Basic up to $375 Enterprise); every other tool here is quote-only. 3Shape Implant Studio shows two different prices across its own vendor pages ($160 vs $290) — we flag that conflict rather than pick one.
Implant planning software all does the same four things on paper: import a CBCT scan, place virtual implants against a library, design a surgical guide, and export it. The real differences show up in three places vendors don't put on the homepage — whether the implant library is open or closed, what a guide actually costs per case once you're past the license fee, and which CAD or imaging ecosystem the tool quietly locks you into. This guide compares 11 tools we could fully verify and is upfront about the one we couldn't (NemoScan).
Independent: vendors cannot buy a position here. We have not tested these products hands-on; every capability is "as documented." Read the disclosure and the methodology.
What implant planning software actually does
Every tool here follows the same workflow: import a CBCT scan (DICOM), place virtual implants from a library against the bone anatomy, design a surgical guide or plan for dynamic navigation, then export for printing or milling. The software itself is rarely the deciding factor — the library, the per-case fee and the ecosystem are.
Open vs closed implant library
This is the single question to ask before anything else: can you plan a case for the implant brand you actually place?
3Shape Implant Studio, coDiagnostiX, exoplan, RealGUIDE, SICAT Implant, and Simplant
Document support for adding implant systems beyond a pre-loaded set. Library size still varies a lot where it's published — see the comparison table.
Blue Sky Plan
Documents a fixed, vendor-controlled library rather than an open add-your-own-brand model.
DTX Studio Implant, Implant Concierge, R2GATE, and SMOP
We found no public statement either way on library openness — ask directly, by the exact implant brands and systems you place, before you buy.
The 11 we could compare, side by side
| Product | Implant library | Guide export fee | Starting price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3Shape Implant Studio | Open, size not published | Not documented | $160–$290 (conflicting sources) |
| Blue Sky Plan | Closed | $6/case | Free software |
| coDiagnostiX | Open, 8,000 implants claimed | Not documented | Free–$375/mo |
| DTX Studio Implant | Not documented | Not documented | Quote-only |
| exoplan | Open, 250 implants claimed | $0 (exocad ecosystem) | Quote-only |
| Implant Concierge | Not documented | $50/case | Free software |
| R2GATE | Not documented | Not documented | Quote-only |
| RealGUIDE | Open, size not published | Not documented | Quote-only |
| SICAT Implant | Open, size not published | Not documented | Quote-only |
| Simplant | Open, 10,000 implants claimed | Not documented | Quote-only |
| SMOP | Not documented | Not documented | $500/yr + per-case |
"Not documented" means we found no public statement either way, not that it definitely doesn't exist — ask directly. 3Shape Implant Studio's two prices come from two different 3Shape-owned pages; we show both rather than guess which is current.
Static guides vs dynamic navigation
A static guide is printed or milled to physically hold the drill at a fixed angle for one case. Dynamic navigation tracks the drill's position on screen in real time instead.
3Shape Implant Studio, coDiagnostiX, and DTX Studio Implant
Document support for real-time guided/dynamic navigation surgery, not just static guide design.
exoplan, Implant Concierge, R2GATE, RealGUIDE, SICAT Implant, and SMOP
Built around designing and exporting a printed or milled static surgical guide.
Which CAD/scanner ecosystem it locks you into
Several of these tools are the implant-planning module of a bigger parent ecosystem, not a standalone purchase:
- coDiagnostiX is part of Straumann's AXS digital ecosystem.
- exoplan is exocad's implant module, built to integrate directly with exocad DentalCAD.
- SICAT Implant and Simplant are both Dentsply Sirona brands; SICAT Implant integrates with SIDEXIS 4 imaging software specifically.
- SMOP (Swissmeda) integrates with Carestream Dental's imaging workflow.
- 3Shape Implant Studio sits inside 3Shape's own scanner and design ecosystem.
None of this blocks CBCT import from other systems — DICOM is the common format — but the deeper design/export workflow is smoothest inside each vendor's own ecosystem.
Tracked, but too little public data: NemoScan
NemoScan is Nemotec's software for digital implantology and 3D guided surgery, focused on comprehensive diagnosis and treatment planning.
Nemotec documents NemoScan as a 3D guided-surgery and diagnosis tool, but we couldn't verify its implant library policy, guide export fee or navigation type from public sources — so it isn't in the main comparison above.
What it costs
The software license is rarely the real cost driver here. coDiagnostiX is the only tool with a published monthly price ($0–$375); everything else is quote-only.
- Ask for the per-case guide export fee in writing. Only 3 of 11 vendors publish one ($0 to $50 in what we found) — at volume, this adds up faster than the license.
- Confirm your specific implant brands are in the library, by name, not just "open vs closed" — an open library's practical value depends entirely on what's actually loaded.
- If you're already inside an ecosystem (Straumann, exocad, Dentsply Sirona, 3Shape, Carestream), price that vendor's own tool first — the integration is usually smoother than a third-party alternative.
Related reading: best dental practice management software if you're also replacing your PMS, and the full implant planning category page for every tracked product.
FAQ
What is the best dental implant planning software?
Among the 11 we could fully compare, none has enough independent reviews to rank by rating. The real decision is your implant library and ecosystem: 3Shape Implant Studio, coDiagnostiX, exoplan, and RealGUIDE document an open library you can add any implant brand to; coDiagnostiX is the only one with published self-serve pricing; exoplan is the only one with a published $0 guide-export fee (inside the exocad ecosystem).
How much does implant planning software cost?
Only coDiagnostiX publishes a monthly price list: free Basic tier, then $79, $209 and $375 a month. Every other tool we track is quote-only. The bigger recurring cost is usually the per-case guide-export fee, not the software license — see the cost section below.
What does "open implant library" mean and why does it matter?
An open implant library lets you plan a case for any implant manufacturer's system, not just the ones the software vendor pre-loaded or that belong to its own parent company. A closed or undocumented library can block you from planning a case for a brand you actually place — ask for the current library list and your specific implant systems by name before buying, not just "do you support open libraries."
What is the difference between a static surgical guide and dynamic navigation?
A static guide is 3D-printed or milled to physically hold the drill at a fixed angle and depth for that one case. Dynamic navigation uses a tracked camera system to show the drill's position on screen in real time, so the surgeon adjusts live instead of being mechanically constrained. Among the tools we track, 3Shape Implant Studio, coDiagnostiX, and DTX Studio Implant document dynamic-navigation support; exoplan, Implant Concierge, R2GATE, RealGUIDE, SICAT Implant, and SMOP are built around static guide design and export.
Does implant planning software work with my CBCT scanner?
Every tool we track here documents DICOM import, which is the standard CBCT export format, so in principle any CBCT unit that exports DICOM should work. What varies is deeper integration — some tools (SICAT Implant with SIDEXIS 4, SMOP with Carestream Dental) are built specifically around one imaging ecosystem's workflow. If you're not on that vendor's imaging hardware, confirm the DICOM import works cleanly with your specific unit before buying.
What is NemoScan and why isn't it in the main comparison?
NemoScan is Nemotec's implant planning tool, but its data completeness falls below our 0.70 bar — key fields like implant library openness, guide export fee and navigation type aren't documented anywhere we could verify. We list what we do know rather than guess at the rest.
Method & sources
We track 12 entities under "implant planning." 11 have enough public data to compare fully and 1 doesn't. We did not test these products hands-on; every capability, library claim and fee in the tables below links to its source via the product page, and only 2 products had any public review to even mention a count — both too thin (1 and 3 reviews) to treat as a rating.
Product facts come from the Denture-ID database, where every field links to the vendor page or document it was taken from — open any product profile to see them. Rankings use the Data Index; vendors cannot pay to change a position. Found an error? Tell us.
- coDiagnostiX — Buy — the only published monthly tier pricing in this category
- exocad — exoplan product page — open library integration, $0 guide-export fee, exocad ecosystem
- 3Shape — Implant Studio (buy page) — $160 price point, conflicting with the $290 shown on 3shape.com
- Implant Concierge — Price Guide — $50 guide export fee
- Straumann — coDiagnostiX for Clinicians — 8,000-implant library claim, Straumann AXS ecosystem
- Denture-ID Data Index methodology — why we flag thin review counts and low-data-completeness products instead of scoring them like the rest